1 min read

Prayer in The Magic of Vajrayana

In The Magic of Vajrayana, Ken McLeod seems to be very big on prayer. One of the chapters at least is devoted to a translated text called The Magic of Faith, which I think is supposed to function as a prayer although I don't recall exactly.

Even the word prayer grates on me. I want to complain about prayer, and this prayer in particular, because it'll be fun for me. I'm serious, but not that serious.

I have a few complaints about this prayer. Some of these may be from confusing it with other traditions of prayer. Regardless, I complain:

  1. It's so long! Three to four pages, depending how I count. Who could memorize all that?
  2. Vowing to release all beings, really? How on earth would one do that? It seems silly to swear to do that which I do not know how I could possibly do—that which nobody has ever done. Even worse, because in theory I could, like any of us, optimize for doing something like that, allowing that I must fall short of exactly fulfilling such a vow—however I have no intention to so optimize.
  3. I dislike the self-deprecating undertones. It sounds degradingly humile at points.
  4. Isn't praying like giving up? Quitting? Who wants to be a quitter?
  5. Or, does prayer mean taking that which is Other as taskmaster? That sounds terrible. A terrible, terrible idea. Surely not.
  6. Prayer to me connotes a regular practice of repeating certain words in a certain order, which I expect eventually to render the words perfunctory.

That seems like enough for now.